|
Book Title: Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders
> pp. [225]-[229]
UNDEFINED: AUTHORS
Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders
Print ISBN 9780195173642, 2005
pp. [225]-[229]
Baker, 1986). Generally, children's and adolescents' use of problem-focused coping strategies has been found to be more associated with positive psychological adjustment than their use of emotion-focused coping strategies. Interestingly, adolescent use of avoidant coping has been found to be associated with high levels of depression in adolescence (Ebata & Moos, 1991). There has been little systematic research on the association between specific types of coping strategies and the development and maintenance of anxiety disorders in adolescence. There also has been little systematic research on which specific coping skills should be taught to adolescents across diverse anxiety-provoking situations. Research in this area is clearly of importance given that coping-skills training represents a major feature of cognitive-behavioral treatments (see Chapter 10). Another characteristic of the individual that relates to cognitions is individuals' perceived control. Specifically, Barlow ( 2001) has suggested that children who experience uncontrollable events early in life may develop a propensity to perceive or process events as not being under their control, which for some youngsters may serve as a risk for the development of anxiety and its disorders. Chorpita, Brown, and Barlow ( 1998) have presented some interesting data showing that perceived control may serve as a mediator of family environment among youths with anxiety disorders. Clearly, further research on the role of perceived control as a protective and risk factor in anxiety disorders is needed, particularly on its specificity (or lack thereof) to anxiety.
As discussed in greater detail in Chapter 9, genetic factors clearly influence the risk for anxiety disorders and, taken together, the epidemiological and genetic data imply distinct biological profiles for the varied anxiety disorders, many of which implicate neurochemical processes. A recent meta-analysis found only a modest genetic contribution to four anxiety categories, and no evidence for a significant effect of shared environment (Hettema, Neale, & Kendler, 2001). When the individual studies themselves are re
viewed, however, inconsistencies emerge with respect to the degree to which genetics were implicated in transmission of anxiety disorders; rates appear to vary as a function of the site of the laboratory, as well as the informant supplying the relevant information. There is evidence for genetic contributions to personality traits such as neuroticism, introversion (Eaves, Eysenck, & Martin, 1989), shyness (Daniels & Plomin, 1985), and behavioral inhibition (DiLalla, Kagan, & Reznick, 1994; Kagan, 1994), each of which may increase risk for the subsequent development of anxiety disorder. In general, many studies of the genetics of anxiety disorders involving children and adolescents have substantive methodological limitations, thus there remains a great deal to discover in this area. Also, it is important to note that the presence of a genetic influence for anxiety disorders does not imply that the course of illness is immutable. From the perspective of prevention, it may be that studying other risk factors in youth at genetic risk for anxiety disorders may prove especially fruitful, and may suggest roads to interventions that reduce the genetic risk.
Parent–Child Interaction and Attachment
All four of the attachment styles in children according to the classification by Ainsworth, Blehar, Waters, and Wall ( 1978) and by Main and Solomon ( 1990)—secure, insecure-avoidant, insecure-ambivalent, and insecure-disorganized —have been found to be represented in children with anxiety disorders. The highest risks for developing an anxiety disorder are associated with disorganized attachment, which is associated with unresolved trauma or loss, and ambivalent attachment (Cassidy, 1995; Manassis, Bradley, Goldberg, Hood, & Swinson, 1994; Warren, Huston, Egeland, & Sroufe, 1997). The specificity of an association between disorganized attachment in terms of its link with a specific type of anxiety disorder, such as separation anxiety disorder, has not been established.
end p.225
PRINTED FROM Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders (www.oup.com/amhi-treatingpreventing)
© Copyright Oxford University Press, 2006. All Rights Reserved
Lutz and Hock ( 1995) examined whether adult mental representations of attachment relationships and memories of childhood experiences with parents contributed to a mother's anxiety about separation from her own infant. Mothers with insecure attachment representations, when asked to remember details of their own childhood, reported more negative recollections of early parental caregiving, particularly rejection and discouragement of independence. Cassidy ( 1995) found that adolescents and adults with generalized anxiety disorder reported more caregiver unresponsiveness, role-reversal and enmeshment, and feelings of anger and vulnerability toward their mothers than controls. Systematic and formal assessments of the adolescents' and adult attachment styles were not conducted in this sample, however.
Manassis et al. ( 1994) examined adult attachment and mother–child attachment in 20 mother–child dyads (children ages 18 to 59 months) in which the mothers suffered from anxiety disorders. The mothers all had insecure adult attachments, and 80% also had insecure attachments with their children. Among the insecurely attached children, 3 of 16 met diagnostic criteria for anxiety disorders; none of the secure children did. Two had separation anxiety disorder (one with disorganized attachment, one with avoidant attachment) and one had avoidant disorder (with disorganized attachment). Insecure children also had higher internalizing scores on the Child Behavior Checklist than those of secure children. When the dyads who had been classified as disorganized and mothers who had been classified as unresolved were assigned their “best” alternate category, and combined with the remaining three attachment categories, a higher than expected rate of ambivalent/resistant attachment and a lower than expected rate of secure attachment were found. Warren et al. ( 1997) studied 172 adolescents aged 17.5 years who had participated in assessments of mother–child attachment at 12 months of age. Of these 172 adolescents, 26 (15%) met diagnostic criteria for anxiety disorders. More of the disordered adolescents were classified as anxious/resistant in infancy than the adolescent without anxiety disorders. More adolescents di
agnosed with other disorders (not anxiety) were, as infants, classified as avoidant. Furthermore, being classified as anxious/resistant attachment doubled the risk of subsequently developing an anxiety disorder and better predicted adolescent anxiety disorders than either maternal anxiety or child temperament. The interaction between anxious/resistant attachment and one aspect of temperament (slow habituation to stimuli) further increased the risk of a subsequent anxiety disorder. However, secure, insecure-avoidant, and insecure-resistant attachment were all represented among the adolescents with anxiety disorders (data on the insecure-disorganized classification were unavailable). Linkages have also been found between attachment and subclinical levels of anxiety. Female undergraduates who were insecurely attached were perceived by their friends as being more anxious than their counterparts who were securely attached (Barnas, Pollina, & Cummings 1991). Crowell, O'Connor, Wollmers, and Sprafkin ( 1991) found that children with behavioral disturbances whose mothers were classified as secure on the Adult Attachment Interview rated themselves as less anxious and depressed than children with behavioral disturbances whose mothers were insecure-dismissing. Cassidy and Berlin ( 1994) reported increased fearfulness across several studies of insecure-ambivalent/resistant children. Belsky and Rovine ( 1987) have suggested a potential linkage between attachment and anxiety when attachment is placed on a spectrum from the style associated with the most overt distress (ambivalent/resistant) to that associated with the least overt distress (avoidant). Secure individuals are in the middle of the spectrum, with some exhibiting relatively high distress and some exhibiting relatively low distress (Belsky & Rovine, 1987). Consistent with Belsky and Rovine ( 1987), 2.5-year-old children who were either insecure-ambivalent/resistant or secure with relatively high distress showed higher indices of fear and separation distress than children in the other attachment classifications (Stevenson-Hinde & Shouldice, 1990). In summary, insecure attachment has been linked with both clinical and subclinical anxiety in children of different age ranges. The link may
end p.226
PRINTED FROM Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders (www.oup.com/amhi-treatingpreventing)
© Copyright Oxford University Press, 2006. All Rights Reserved
be stronger when the child also has temperamental vulnerability to anxiety, although the evidence for this is not as clear. Limitations of this research include paucity of prospective studies, the varying definitions of anxiety (e.g., anxiety symptoms, anxiety disorders) used across studies, and small sample sizes.
The research conducted on parenting has focused primarily on parental rearing styles, with the latter conceptualized along two orthogonal dimensions: warmth versus hostility, and control versus autonomy (Boer, 1998; Cassidy, 1995; Dadds, Barrett, Rapee, & Ryan, 1996; Lutz & Hock, 1995; Manassis et al., 1994; Rapee 1997; Siqueland, Kendall, & Steinberg, 1996; Warren et al., 1997).
In a meta-analysis of five studies, with a total of 463 patients in the experimental groups, Gerlsma, Emmelkamp, and Arrindell ( 1990) found that adults with phobias reported a parental rearing style characterized by less affection and more control. Studies of adults meeting diagnostic criteria for panic disorder or social phobia/avoidant personality disorder have demonstrated a similar recollection of child-rearing patterns, in that these adults view their parents, and their relationship with them, as low in affection and overcontrolling (Rapee, 1997). Empirical research has documented an influence of parental rearing styles on the development of anxiety (see Rapee, 1997, for review). Interestingly, adults with insecure-preoccupied attachments frequently report parental rejection and control (Main & Goldwyn, 1991), which suggests that parenting style may be related to adult attachment status.
Prospective reports and behavioral observations.
In an early study, Bush, Melamed, & Cockrell ( 1989), using a self-report measure of parental rearing patterns, found parental reported use of positive reinforcement, modeling, and persuasion was associated with lower levels of child anxiety during their child's undergoing of a fearful medical procedure; parental use of punishment, physical force, and reinforcement of dependency was associated with higher levels during the medical procedure. Siqueland et al.
( 1996) found that parents of children with anxiety disorders were rated by observers as less granting of psychological autonomy than were the parents of “normal” controls. In addition, children with anxiety disorders rated their mothers and fathers as less accepting and less granting of psychological autonomy compared to control children's ratings of their parents. Direct observations of parent–child interactions have provided further evidence of family processes that may be specific to families of children with anxiety disorders, and these processes may serve to either bring out and/or maintain these disorders in children (e.g., Chorpita, Albano, & Barlow, 1996; Dadds et al., 1996; Ginsburg, Silverman, & Kurtines, 1995). For example, Dadds et al. ( 1996) studied specific sequences of communication exchanged between parents and children (ages 7 to 14) in a discussion of ambiguous hypothetical situations. Parents of children with anxiety disorders ( n = 66) were less likely to grant and reward autonomy of thought and action than controls ( n = 18). Dadds et al. also found that these parents fostered cautiousness and avoidance of taking a social risk by modeling caution, providing information about risk, expressing doubt about the child's competency, and rewarding the child for avoidance by expressing agreement and nurturance when the child decided he or she would not join in with the other children. Dadds et al. referred to this finding as the FEAR effect (Family Enhancement of Avoidant and Aggressive Responses). In a study with 16 children (mean age = 11 years) of agoraphobic mothers and 16 children of mothers with no history of psychopathology matched by age, gender, and socioeconomic status (Capps, Sigman, Sena, & Henker, 1996), agoraphobic mothers reported more maternal separation anxiety with regard to their child than the control group. Maternal separation anxiety correlated negatively with children's perceived control (Capps et al., 1996). The effect probably is best interpreted as the result of a reciprocal relation between caregiver and child: when a child is more anxious, there may be greater cause for the parent's anxiety about separation. More recently, Hudson and Rapee ( 2002) studied 57 children and adolescents (37 children
end p.227
PRINTED FROM Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders (www.oup.com/amhi-treatingpreventing)
© Copyright Oxford University Press, 2006. All Rights Reserved
with anxiety disorders, 20 nonclinic-referred children; aged 7 to 16 years) and found that mothers and fathers were overly involved not only with their anxiety-disordered child but also with the child's sibling (without anxiety disorders). The authors concluded that because parental overinvolvement does not occur exclusively in youths with anxiety disorders, it probably is not simply a response to difficulties with anxiety and coping that they have observed with the diagnosed youth. It also suggests that parental overinvolvement does not in and of itself cause anxiety disorders. Anxious parents could increase their offsprings' risk of anxiety disorders by (1) having difficulty modeling appropriate coping strategies; (2) reacting to their children's fears negatively because they represent an aspect of themselves that they would rather deny; or (3) becoming overly concerned about their children's anxiety, resulting in overprotection and thus reducing opportunities for desensitization. The latter two reactions are consistent with dismissive and preoccupied adult attachment types, respectively. Anxious parents who are securely attached, by contrast, may be able to empathize with their children's fears, which may then be perceived as supportive. Thus, the transmission of parental anxiety may depend on the interaction between attachment and parental psychopathology (Radke-Yarrow, DeMulder, & Belmont, 1995).
Peer, School, and Community
The ecology of adolescent development and culture includes an expanded network of peer, school, and community affiliations. The transition to middle and high school constitutes a period of high developmental risk, in which there is an increased incidence of school truancy, failure and dropout, engagement in high-risk sexual and self-injurious behaviors, smoking and drug use, initiation into gangs, and contact with the juvenile justice system. It is also a period of increased exposure to interpersonal violence. For example, in 1999, almost 10% of 9th to 12th graders reported being hit or physically hurt by a boyfriend or girlfriend. In the sections below,
particular high-risk activities engaged in by adolescents and their associated risk with anxiety are discussed.
Initiation into cigarette smoking in adolescents is recognized as a major public health problem. As summarized by Upadhyaya, Deas, Brady, and Kruesi ( 2002) from a number of national surveys, approximately 3,000 adolescents start smoking each day, resulting in about 21% of high school seniors smoking daily, and a total of 4 million adolescent smokers. Smoking prevention and early treatment are important components of universal and selective public health prevention strategies, especially given that the American Health Association estimates that addiction to tobacco during adolescence accounts for 80% of adult smokers. As Upadhyaya et al. ( 2002) discuss, there is continuing interest in the interaction between onset of adolescent psychiatric conditions and smoking behavior, including experimental smoking and cessation difficulty. Among the disorders studied, Johnson et al. ( 2000) report that heavy cigarette smoking (defined as over 20 cigarettes per day) is associated with higher rates of agoraphobia, anxiety, and panic disorders in adolescents. Other studies have reported an even stronger association of adolescent smoking with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (Johnson et. al., 2000) and major depressive disorder (Dierker et al., 2001). Most of these studies note the importance of the relationship between peer smoking influences and individual psychiatric vulnerabilities. The general conclusion is two-pronged: first, smoking prevention and cessation programs need to incorporate screening for adolescent psychiatric disorders, including anxiety disorders and, second, attention to adolescent anxiety and comorbid disorders need to include strategies to address risks of tobacco addiction.
Adolescence is a developmental period in which experimentation with alcohol and drugs is com
end p.228
PRINTED FROM Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders (www.oup.com/amhi-treatingpreventing)
© Copyright Oxford University Press, 2006. All Rights Reserved
mon. It also is a time of development risk for early onset of alcohol and substance abuse and dependence. Nelson and Wittchen ( 1998) found that among youth and young adults, the peak incidence of alcohol disorders occurred at 16–17 years of age. Alcohol and drug use problems in adolescents are a strong predictive factor of adult alcohol and drug dependence (Swadi, 1999). Studies of substance abuse and alcohol motivation in adolescents suggest a multifactorial explanatory framework. Among the many factors, Comeau, Stuart, and Loba ( 2001) found that high anxiety sensitivity predicts conformity motives for alcohol and marijuana use, whereas anxiety traits are associated with coping motives for alcohol and cigarette use. Zucker, Craske, Barrios, and Holguin ( 2002) reported that among young adults with panic disorder, up to one in five cases had an onset related to an adolescent experience with a psychoactive drug. In a review of studies of adolescent use of the recreational drug “ecstasy,” Montoya, Sorrentino, Lukas, and Price ( 2002) found a strong association between repeated drug use and anxiety disturbances, with potential neurobiological consequences that are of concern within this critical developmental stage. Initiation and use of alcohol and drugs among adolescents are also related to life stresses, including traumatic events (Wills, Vaccaro, & McNammar, 1992). In one study, substance-abusing adolescents were found to be five times more likely to have a history of trauma and concurrent posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) compared to a community sample (Deykin & Buka, 1997). In a large study of adolescents enrolled in four drug treatment programs, a high positive correlation was found between severity of posttraumatic stress symptoms and higher levels of substance use and HIV risk behavior (Stevens, Murphy, & McNight, 2003). As with cigarette addiction, prevention strategies for adolescent substance abuse need to include early intervention for anxiety vulnerable and traumatized youth and at the same time recognize that prevention or early intervention for adolescent substance abuse may also constitute an anxiety disorder prevention strategy.
Gang Affiliation and Other Criminal Behavior
Gang affiliation is a serious cultural problem in adolescence. There are an estimated 24,000 gangs, with over 772,000 members active across the United States (U.S. Department of Justice, 2002). There is a complexity to youth involvement in gangs. Many studies have examined the confluence of risk factors that predict gang membership, including neighborhood, family, school, peer group, and individual variables (Hill, Levermore, Twaite, & Jones, 1996). There is an emerging literature about the extent of trauma and loss exposure associated with gang membership and delinquent behavior more generally (Wood, Foy, Layne, Pynoos, & James, 2002). Despite high rates of trauma exposure prior to gang membership, commonly youth report that their worst traumatic experiences are gang related and the source of current PTSD symptoms (Wood et al., 2002). Ages 11–13 are primary years for solicitation and inculcation into gang affiliation and activities, contributing to years of increased trauma and loss exposure during adolescence. Consequently, intervention programs to prevent youth from becoming involved in gangs should be considered an adjunct prevention strategy for adolescent PTSD. Adolescence is also the time when involvement in the justice system accelerates. Approximately 1.8 million youth go through the juvenile justice system each year, with over 360,000 detained and 176,000 incarcerated (U.S. Department of Justice, 2002). Recently, attention has turned to the high prevalence of adolescent psychiatric disorder present among juvenile justice detainees. Of importance, the rate of anxiety disorders is as high as one in three and equal to or exceeds those of mood disorder. Of the anxiety disorders, studies vary in the prevalence of specific anxiety disorders. Studies that have assessed PTSD have found it to be among the highest (Wasserman, McReynolds, Lucal, Fisher, & Santos, 2002). Interestingly, separation anxiety disorder among adolescents (an age-range where it is less expected) is surprisingly high among African-American and Hispanic and Latino detained youth (Teplin, Abram, McClelland,
end p.229
doi:10.1093/9780195173642.003.0012
|
|
|
|