|
Book Title: Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders
> pp. [315]-[319]
UNDEFINED: AUTHORS
Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders
Print ISBN 9780195173642, 2005
pp. [315]-[319]
mal. In a recent review, Stice ( 2002) concluded that there was some evidence that negative affect, perfectionism, and early menarche are potentiating factors that amplify the effects of other risk factors. He also noted that although early menarche did not emerge as a significant risk factor for eating pathology in univariate models, it did appear to interact with life stressors to predict emergence of negative affect and eating disturbances (Stice, 2002). These promising leads should be followed in future studies.
How Are Risk Factors Acquired?
As noted above, prospective studies have suggested that the perceived pressure to be thin, internalization of a thin ideal, body dissatisfaction, and negative affect are risk factors for the development of bulimic symptoms, and other studies have begun to examine the development of such factors (Stice, 2002). Their acquisition is undoubtedly complex, involving the adolescent's innate susceptibility, developmental stage, and exposure to sociocultural factors such as teasing from family members and peers, social modeling (e.g., Furman & Thompson, 2002; Jackson, Grilo, & Masheb, 2000; Stice, Maxfield, & Wells, 2003; van den Berg, Wertheim, Thompson, & Paxton, 2002), and media pressure (e.g., Field, Camargo, Taylor, Berkey, & Colditz, 1999; Field et al., 2001; Taylor et al., 1998). Although few longitudinal studies have demonstrated the developmental sequence of exposure to risk factors, interventions designed to reduce the impact of risk factors may need to address a range of sociocultural factors.
A number of factors, including perceived pressure to be thin, thin-ideal internalization, body dissatisfaction, and negative affect, have been identified as risk factors for the development of bulimic symptoms. Some studies suggest that attempted dieting is a risk factor for the development of bulimic symptoms, whereas other data indicate that actual experimentally prescribed dietary restriction is not a risk factor. It is not clear whether dysfunctional dieting, especially
severe caloric restriction, is a risk factor for full-syndrome bulimia nervosa. Low self-esteem, perfectionism, early menarche, and impulsivity do not appear to be risk factors for bulimic symptoms. The conclusions from the studies of risk factors for bulimia nervosa indicate that prevention programs that target thin-ideal internalization, pressure to be thin, modeling of eating disturbances, body dissatisfaction, and negative affect may prove useful in preventing the development of bulimic symptoms. Although currently unproven, it seems logical to assume that a reduction in bulimic symptoms in a population would lead to a reduction in the incidence of full-syndrome bulimia nervosa as well.
TREATMENT OF OBESITY AS A RISK FACTOR FOR EATING DISORDERS
As discussed previously, although the empirical evidence is mixed, dieting is frequently implicated in the pathogenesis of eating disorders (Schmidt, 2002). The presumed association between dieting and the development of symptoms of eating disorders has led school-based eating disorder prevention programs to warn students about the ill effects of dieting (e.g., Kater, Rohwer, & Levine, 2000). With obesity rapidly becoming a major public health problem for America's youth, it is important to understand whether treatments for obesity, specifically recommendations to restrict caloric intake, increase the risk for the development of eating disorders. Recent data indicate that 15.5% of adolescents are overweight, a 3-fold increase since 1980 (National Center for Health Statistics, 2003; Troiano, Flegal, Kuczmarski, Campbell, & Johnson, 1995), and an additional 22% of adolescents are at risk of being overweight, compared to 15.7% in 1980 (Troiano et al., 1995). Approximately 80% of overweight teenagers will become obese adults and consequently will experience increased risks of cardiovascular disease, hyperlipidemia, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, gallbladder disease, several cancers, and psychosocial complications (Casey, Dwyer, Coleman, & Valadian, 1992; Garn, Sullivan, & Hawthorne, 1989). Adults suffer adverse health effects as a result of teenage obesity (DiPietro, Mossberg, &
end p.315
PRINTED FROM Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders (www.oup.com/amhi-treatingpreventing)
© Copyright Oxford University Press, 2006. All Rights Reserved
Stunkard, 1994; Must, Jacques, Dallal, Bajema, & Dietz, 1992), but obese teens may not be spared from health complications until they reach adulthood. Twenty years ago, Type 2 diabetes was rare in children and adolescents. However, recent reports demonstrated that one third of adolescents diagnosed with diabetes had the Type 2, or adult-onset, form of this disease, which represents a 10-fold increase from rates in 1982 (Pinhas-Hamiel et al., 1996; Glaser 1997; Phillips & Young, 2000). Investigators fear that diabetes progresses more quickly in youth than in adults (Styne, 2001). A combination of decreased caloric intake (i.e., dieting) and increased physical activity is the cornerstone of weight management in overweight adolescents, as in obese adults. Some clinicians and researchers fear, however, that dieting may increase the risk of eating disorders, particularly in adolescent females, and that weight loss interventions may do more harm than good (Garner & Wooley, 1991; Hirschmann & Munter, 1988; Polivy & Herman, 1985). By contrast, obesity experts generally believe that early intervention is desirable. Family support for change is likely to be available, eating and activity habits may be more amenable to modification, and adipose tissue cell proliferation may be curtailed (Goldfield & Epstein, 2002). Early treatment may also be cost-effective. Preventing overweight children and adolescents from becoming obese adults could reduce the health-care costs of treating obesity-related complications. The question of whether dieting increases the risk of eating disorders in overweight adolescents and older children who seek weight loss is particularly important given the increasing rates of obesity. However, the vast majority of adolescent dieters do not develop eating disorders, as 44% of teenage girls report trying to lose weight, but the prevalence of eating disorders is between 1% (anorexia nervosa) and 3% (bulimia nervosa) of women, and prevalence rates among men are approximately one tenth of those observed in women (Hoek, 2002). As discussed above, other factors, including a genetic predisposition and negative affect, appear to contribute to the development of eating disorders in the presence of attempts to diet (Schmidt, 2002). Other issues must also be examined when considering whether dieting is a risk factor for the development of eating disorders in overweight adolescents. First, studies of average weight or lean youth may have limited relevance to overweight adolescents. Although average-weight individuals experience adverse behavioral and psychological effects from severe caloric restriction (Keys, Brozek, Henschel, Mickelson, & Taylor, 1950), obese adults who have lost 10% of their initial weight have shown improvements in mood and premorbid binge eating frequency (National Task Force on the Prevention and Treatment of Obesity, 2000). A second consideration already discussed is that dieting can take many forms, from unhealthy weight control practices such as fasting or starvation, to moderate energy restriction, to a preoccupation with purportedly “good” and “bad” foods. Some interventions would appear more likely than others to be associated with adverse effects, therefore, it is important to understand the types of treatments used with overweight or obese children and adolescents.
Weight Loss Interventions for Children and Adolescents
Effective management of overweight in children and adolescents consists of diet, physical activity, and behavior change, and often requires parental participation (Goldfield, Raynor, & Epstein, 2002). Dietary change may include reduction of calorie or fat intake, or improved adherence to dietary guidelines, such as the Food Guide Pyramid (Epstein, Myers, Raynor, & Saelens, 1998). A popular approach to diet modification in youth is provided by the Stoplight Diet for Children, which classifies foods into red ( stop), yellow ( caution), or green ( go) categories based on caloric value and nutrient density (Epstein & Squires, 1988). Typically, the initial goal is to limit intake to 1,000–1,300 calories per day, adjusted to promote a weight loss of 0.25 kg/week. To increase physical activity, programs typically encourage structured aerobic exercise, such as swimming, jogging, or basketball, and lifestyle activity, which increases physical activity throughout the day (e.g., using the stairs rather
end p.316
PRINTED FROM Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders (www.oup.com/amhi-treatingpreventing)
© Copyright Oxford University Press, 2006. All Rights Reserved
than escalators). Preliminary studies demonstrated that lifestyle activity was more effective than structured exercise in facilitating the maintenance of weight loss (Goldfield et al., 2002). Reducing sedentary behaviors, including watching television and playing video games, has also been shown to contribute significantly to weight management (Epstein et al., 1995). Parental participation in treatment is critical for children and also benefits adolescents (Goldfield et al., 2002). Parents may reward changes in their child's diet or physical activity, or modify their own eating or activity habits to model healthy behaviors. Similarly, parents can limit high-fat and high-sugar foods available in the home, while increasing consumption of fruits, vegetables, and other healthy choices. One study found that using parents as the exclusive agents for their child's behavior change resulted in greater decreases in overweight than treating the child alone (Golan, Weizman, Apterm, & Fainaru, 1998). Family-based behavioral programs reduce children's percentage of overweight by as much as 25% and produce successful weight maintenance for as long as 10 years (Goldfield & Epstein, 2002). More typical reductions in percentage overweight have ranged from 5% to 15% (Goldfield et al., 2002). Decreases in weight (or fat) have been associated with significant reductions in systolic and diastolic blood pressure, fasting serum cholesterol, triglycerides, and hyperinsulinemia, and significant increases in high-density lipoprotein serum cholesterol (Epstein et al., 1998).
Effects of Dieting and Weight Loss on Eating Behavior
A family-based behavior modification program for severe pediatric overweight (Levine, Ringham, Kalarchian, Wisniewski, & Marcus, 2001) produced an average decrease in overweight of 11% during treatment, but this reduction was not maintained approximately 8 months later. Symptoms of eating disorders were measured by the Children's Eating Attitudes Test (ChEAT), which is designed to assess attitudes toward eating and dieting behavior, perceived
body image, obsessions and preoccupations with food, and dieting practices. At follow-up, preoccupation with dieting, unhealthy dieting behaviors, and concerns about being overweight decreased. Thus, neither significant weight loss nor weight regain caused an increase in eating disorder symptoms. Epstein and colleagues evaluated an intervention in which all participants followed the standard Stoplight Diet for Children intervention (described above), and some also received problem-solving skills training (Epstein, Paluch, Saelens, Ernst, & Wilfley, 2001). Follow-up assessments, conducted 18 months after completion of treatment, indicated that percentage overweight decreased an average of 13% across conditions. Weight dissatisfaction, purging and restricting, and total symptoms of disordered eating, assessed by the Kids' Eating Disorder Survey (KEDS; Childress, Jarrell, & Brewerton, 1993), showed no significant changes over time. A third study evaluated a cognitive-behavior modification (CBM) program that taught self-regulation and problem-solving skills and promoted lifestyle change (Braet & Van Winckel, 2000). Cognitive-behavior modification was delivered in a group, individual, or summer-camp format and was compared to a one-session advice condition. At the 4.6-year follow-up assessment, percentage overweight (which did not differ between groups) had decreased an average of 11% from baseline. None of the participants had anorexia nervosa at follow-up. Assessment with the Dutch Eating Behavior Questionnaire (DEBQ; Van Strien, Frijters, Bergers, & Defares, 1986) indicated that external eating decreased and restrained eating increased between baseline and follow-up, which indicated that the program helped children control external food stimuli and develop the restraint necessary for weight control. Emotional eating, also measured with the DEBQ, did not change. Five participants (9%) scored 1 standard deviation above the reference group mean for the bulimia subscale of the Eating Disorders Inventory, which indicates a greater risk for developing an eating disorder. However, the proportion of higher-risk participants did not appear elevated when compared with community samples of adolescents. A 10-year follow-up study, the longest to date,
end p.317
PRINTED FROM Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders (www.oup.com/amhi-treatingpreventing)
© Copyright Oxford University Press, 2006. All Rights Reserved
evaluated outcomes for participants enrolled in one of four weight control programs during childhood (Epstein, Myers, Raynor, & Saelens, 1998). All of the interventions were family based and used the Stoplight Diet for Children. At follow-up, percentage overweight decreased an average of 10%–20% for participants in most treatment groups, whereas participants in control groups increased their percentage overweight by as much as 12%. Four percent of participants reported that they had been treated for bulimia nervosa over the course of the 10-year follow-up, and none reported treatment for anorexia nervosa. These rates are consistent with rates from community samples. These four studies suggest that professionally administered weight loss interventions pose minimal risks of precipitating eating disorders in overweight children and adolescents. Cross-sectional studies examining the relationship between dieting and binge eating in clinical populations support this view, as past participation in diet programs does not appear to increase the occurrence of binge eating (Berkowitz, Stunkard, & Stallings, 1993). Similarly, about half of adults with binge eating disorder report that dieting did not precede the onset of their disorder (Yanovski, 2002).
Effects of Dieting on Psychological Status
Dieting and weight loss have also been identified as precipitants to adverse emotional reactions, including depression, anxiety, and irritability (Stunkard, 1957; Stunkard & Rush, 1974). Myers, Raynor, and Epstein ( 1998) evaluated children's psychological status, as determined by mothers' reports on the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL; Achenbach, 1991), while they participated in a family-based behavioral program. From baseline to 1-year follow-up, participants' percentage overweight decreased an average of 20%, and during this time, global child psychopathology decreased significantly, while global competence increased. The proportion of children who met clinical criteria for at least one behavior problem decreased from 29% at baseline to 13% at follow-up. Improvements in some aspects of psychological status, including somatic complaints and so
cial competence, were positively associated with weight loss. Levine and colleagues ( 2001) found significant reductions in symptoms of depression and anxiety at the end of treatment that were maintained at 8-month follow-up. Epstein and colleagues ( 2001) observed that total behavior problems and internalizing behavior problems (as measured by the CBCL) decreased significantly at 18-month follow-up. Twelve percent of participants reported seeking treatment for depression during the decade of the Epstein, Valoski, Wing, & McCurley ( 1994) follow-up, a rate that does not appear high for children who have sought professional weight reduction services (Goldsmith et al., 1992). These findings, as a whole, do not indicate that dieting has a negative effect on mood (e.g., Polivy & Herman, 1985).
Evidence from Research on Obese Adults
Professionally administered weight control programs for overweight youth do not appear to precipitate disordered eating, a finding supported by research on the effects of dieting on binge eating behaviors in obese adults (National Task Force on the Prevention and Treatment of Obesity, 2000; Wilson, 2002). Behavioral programs that prescribed moderate caloric restriction were associated with significant decreases in binge eating episodes in individuals with preexisting binge eating pathology. Studies that used very low–calorie diets (VLCDs) also generally reported improvements in binge eating, although one investigation reported an increase in this behavior (Telch & Agras, 1993). In reviewing the literature, the National Task Force on the Prevention and Treatment of Obesity ( 2000) concluded that dieting and weight loss, in overweight or obese adults, were not associated with the development of eating disorders, and that weight loss was associated with improvements in depression, anxiety, and related complications. The inclusion, in most programs, of behavior therapy to promote weight loss may have contributed to the observed improvements in mood (Wadden, Stunkard, & Liebschutz, 1988; Wadden, Stunkard, & Smoller, 1986). Long-term studies also found that weight regain, while up
end p.318
PRINTED FROM Treating and Preventing Adolescent Mental Health Disorders (www.oup.com/amhi-treatingpreventing)
© Copyright Oxford University Press, 2006. All Rights Reserved
setting to dieters, was not associated with significant increases in depression, anxiety, or binge eating (Foster, Wadden, Kendall, Stunkard and Vogt, 1996; National Task Force, 2000; Wilson, 2002).
Professionally administered weight loss programs for overweight children and adolescents generally do not increase symptoms of eating disorders and are associated with significant improvements in psychological status. Thus, concerns about the possible adverse effects of dieting should not deter our nation's growing number of overweight youth from pursuing sensible methods to lose weight or, at least, to prevent the progression of adiposity. A critical issue to address in future research is how to craft public health messages that are health promoting. Clearly approaches aimed at moderation (neither too much nor too little) could effectively target overweight children and youth who tend toward caloric restriction associated with eating disorders. Given the electricity and lack of clarity associated with the term dieting, other terminology should be sought that focuses on healthy portion sizes, moderation of intake, and healthy levels of physical activity.
PREVENTION OF EATING DISORDERS
The prevention of eating disorders remains an important but elusive goal. The literature on eating disorders prevention is relatively limited compared to the voluminous work on the prevention of other problems seen in adolescence. For instance, Durlak and Wells ( 1997) used meta-analysis to examine 177 primary prevention programs designed to prevent behavioral and social problems in young people under the age of 18. Tobler et al. ( 2000) found 207 universal prevention programs designed to reduce substance abuse. Nevertheless, the existing data can be useful in evaluating the current state of research on the prevention of eating disorders. This section reviews empirical studies of prevention, with a focus on universal and targeted
prevention activities. In universal prevention, attempts are made to reduce the incidence of a disease by eliminating or reducing risk factors in a population. Increasing exercise levels and reducing intake of high levels of saturated fat to reduce the prevalence of obesity would be categorized as a universal prevention intervention. Ideally, the reduction of risk factors would decrease the incidence of eating disorders such that the benefits of the change outweigh any attendant risks for the population as a whole. Targeted preventive interventions focus on reducing risk factors in individuals who are at high risk of developing subthreshold or threshold eating disorder syndromes. A more in-depth definition of universal and targeted prevention programs is given in the Introduction to this book. For both universal and targeted interventions, risk factors must be identified and subsequently tested to determine whether a reduction in the risk factor decreases the incidence of the disorder. No risk factor for eating disorders has yet passed this test. Although some investigators have argued that preventive activities should also focus on “protective” factors, such as building higher levels of self-esteem to reduce the risk of developing an eating disorder, no such protective factors have been identified in prospective risk factor studies. Targeted preventive interventions must identify high-risk individuals accurately, which could involve the use of highly sensitive and specific screening tools to partition a population into no-risk, high-risk, or case (diagnosed with the disorder) groups. High-risk individuals could receive targeted preventive interventions, or monitoring, whereas cases could be referred for treatment. But there is currently no instrument that can satisfactorily partition individuals into these groups.
Most studies evaluating universal prevention efforts target older students and use curricula designed to change the knowledge, beliefs, attitudes, intentions, and behaviors of individual students. Most programs promote healthy weight regulation, discourage calorie-restrictive dieting, and address ways in which body image
end p.319
doi:10.1093/9780195173642.003.0016
|
|
|
|